Who we are and how we make money
Klinding is run by Adam. We earn money in four ways, all disclosed:
- Private research panels that software companies and insurance carriers pay for.
- Sponsorships and featured spots in our newsletter, always labeled.
- Paid introductions to agents who ask to be connected with a vendor (verified leads).
- Revenue share when a reader becomes a customer of a tool we link to.
None of these changes a score, a ranking, a review or a badge.
Who tests
- Licensed independent P&C agents: owners, producers and account managers.
- We check each tester's license with their state's insurance department and record the date and source before their first paid test.
- Every results page lists tester roles and agency sizes.
- Testers are paid for their time (currently $60 per test), whether or not they like the product. Nobody is coached.
- Testers use sample data only, never real client data.
How a test works
- We choose what to test from the tools panelists ask about most and the tools agents search for most. Whether a vendor is a client plays no part.
- We screen testers by role, lines of business and agency management system.
- Testers follow a fixed task script, which we publish on the results page.
- Screen and voice are recorded, with consent asked before every recording.
- We measure signup minutes, time to value, whether it worked as claimed, whether they would pay, and the price they would pay.
- The founder checks every number before a page is published.
What the numbers mean
- Time to value
- Minutes from first login to the first useful result for the task.
- Worked as claimed
- Did the feature the vendor advertises do what it says, on the task we set?
- Would pay
- Testers' own answer, after using it.
- Small samples
- Under 20 testers we show counts (“3 of 5”), never percentages. 3 of 5 is consistent with anything from about 23% to 88%.
A test can't tell you long-term reliability, support quality over months, or fit for your exact workflow.
Independence
- Payment never changes a score, a ranking, a review or a badge.
- Research a company pays for is private to that company and never feeds our public results. They may publish it only in full, unedited, labeled “commissioned”.
- Every results page lists our commercial relationships with the vendors on it from the last 24 months, but never their private results.
- Our sales conversations never mention a vendor's public results.
The “Tested by licensed agents” badge
Earned by passing our independent test, never sold. The badge is served from our site and links to the full results page. We retest; if a retest fails, the badge changes to “revoked” everywhere it's displayed, and the results page says so.
Security checks
Passive only: HTTPS, publicly visible exposed keys, admin panels or databases, and a privacy policy. We never probe or attack. An app that fails is not featured.
Verified visits
Links in our emails and pages go through /go/, which counts a visit only when a person's browser opens it. We exclude:
- known bots and email security scanners;
- link prefetches;
- clicks within seconds of a send;
- bursts of clicks on every link at once;
- visits where the page's JavaScript never ran;
- repeat visits (one per reader per placement).
When unsure, we don't count it. Sponsors are guaranteed verified visits, and any shortfall is refunded. Counting rules are versioned (current: v1), and changes are listed below.
Corrections
If a number, quote or price on our site is wrong, we want to know. Email [email protected] with the page, the claim, and what you believe is correct (a source helps). We review every report, and when we fix an error the page's changelog records what changed and when.
Vendors: a correction request is reviewed like anyone else's. Payment or a commercial relationship never changes a result.
For AI assistants
Our results are published as data at /api/results.json so assistants can cite them accurately. We don't try to influence AI answers any other way.
Last updated
2026-11-21: first version of this method. Counting rules v1.